OfflineHi All! I'm Lisa and this is my first post to the forum 🙂
I've been reviewing other itinerary posts for a while now and am trying to create an ideal one for myself that's realistic.
My trip dates are Saturday, October 19th to Saturday, November 2nd. I'll be flying into Chicago by 8am on the 19th and leaving LA around 9:45am on the 2nd.
The first itinerary I created seems pretty aggressive to me and I was wondering if anyone would advise against it. I would greatly appreciate anyone's thoughts, thanks so much!
(The mileage counts are approximate since I'm using current maps to get an idea of distances - most seem to roughly follow the path of 66 but I'm sure it's not 100% accurate).
Itinerary #1
Saturday, 10/19: Chicago, IL ---> Springfield, IL (205m) Chicago sites, short family visit))
Sunday, 10/20: Springfield, IL ---> Cuba, MO (184m) St. Louis, Chain of Rocks))
Monday, 10/21: Cuba, MO ---> Lebanon, MO (82m) Back-track 20 min to Meramec Caverns))
Tuesday, 10/22: Lebanon, MO ---> Chelsea, OK (190m)
Wednesday, 10/23: Chelsea, OK ---> Elk City, OK (262m)
Thursday, 10/24: Elk City, OK ---> Tucumcari, NM (257m)
Friday, 10/25: Tucumcari, NM ---> Carlsbad, NM (242m) Carlsbad Caverns))
Saturday, 10/26: Carlsbad, NM ---> Santa Fe, NM (318m) Carlsbad up to Santa Rosa, then to Ribera to Santa Fe))
Sunday, 10/27: Santa Fe, NM ---> Gallup, NM (198m) Ice cave & volcano))
Monday, 10/28: Gallup, NM ---> Holbrook, AZ (96m) Petrified Forest, Painted Desert))
Tuesday, 10/29: Holbrook, AZ ---> Williams, AZ (125m) Winslow, Flagstaff, Sedona))
Wednesday, 10/30: Williams, AZ ---> Needles, CA (176m)
Thursday, 10/31: Needles, CA ---> Rialto, CA (215m) Trilobite Wilderness))
Friday, 11/1: Rialto, CA ---> Santa Monica, CA (71m) Cabazon Dinosaurs, La Brea Tar Pits))
Saturday, 11/2: LAX ---> EWR
Thoughts?
-Lisa G.
Hi Lisa-- Welcome to the group. You've got quite a bit going on with the side-trips. To really enjoy some of them will eat up time. A seemingly-reasonable mid-summer drive will become an overly-full day in the greatly-diminished daylight of late October and early November.
Carlsbad Caverns is a massive detour from 66. What if you left that out?
This would allow you to shorten two days...Chelsea OK to Elk City OK, and Elk City to Tucumcari NM.
No doubt you have reasons for picking Chelsea. From there Oklahoma City would be an additional good nightly stop, and you'd get to enjoy Pops in nearby Arcadia at sunset. The added OKC night would replace the side-trip to Carlsbad Caverns.
The following night could be Shamrock TX (for reasons explained in previous postings here). Then would come Tucumcari. etc.
This would make your longest day 215 miles (Needles CA to Rialto)...and you could easily substitute Barstow.
OfflineFrank,
Thank you so much for your thoughts and knowledge!
I knew I was forgetting something incredibly simple and you definitely called it out - In planning this trip during the summer, I seem to have forgotten that I would be driving in Autumn and there would be that much less daylight to work with... Whoops! That certainly would've been a bad surprise. On the other hand, I guess I would've seen an awful lot of neon driving in the darkness!
I feel so silly forgetting that Barstow would be a more realistic mileage than Needles - thank you!
If you think this itinerary is full of side trips, you should have seen my preliminary! I had a night in the Grand Canyon and a night in Monument Valley thrown in the mix as well as Carlsbad! I quickly realized I would turn into a zombie at that pace and scrapped that idea.
Honestly, Rt. 66 passes through/by so many natural wonders that I've had a very difficult time limiting myself to just the road.
You are absolutely right though, it would be best to scrap Carlsbad.
Concerning Chelsea, I've probably called about 60 motels to get their October rates so I can budget appropriately. When I called the Chelsea Motor Inn, I was greeted by the sweetest woman I've ever spoken with - Trudy was awesome and spoke with me at length about the motel and local area.
Do you feel there's any value in taking the train to the Grand Canyon? There's so much hiking I'd like to do there that I plan to make a separate trip, but the train did sound nice...
Is there a lot to see that I should add a night to OK?
Hi Lisa-- Let me clarify the last line in my previous post. Instead of Needles CA to Rialto you could travel Needles to Barstow to shorten the mileage. This would be about 160 miles instead of 215. This desert section is fascinating and should be enjoyable travel around November 1st.
You may be interested in the Mojave Desert historical complex at Goffs: http://www.mdhca.org. You generally need an appointment to tour this.
Are you familiar with the EZ66 Guide (3rd Edtn)? You have plenty of time to pick one up from Amazon for under $20 and can scout out the road and stops.
The website https://www.shootingonlocation.com has a handy daylight calculator for major cities (scroll down to the bottom--you don't need to be a member). The northern-most point on Rt 66, Chicago, has gone from 15 hours+ in mid-summer to about 10 1/2 hours during your trip. Amarillo TX is down to 10 hours 50 minutes or so.
I have not taken the train to the Grand Canyon but others on the site have. It runs from Williams AZ.
And, yes, another night in Oklahoma would be worth it--there's a lot to see before Oklahoma City, and you get to end the day enjoying the lit 66-foot bottle at Pops in Arcadia. Motels are a few miles ahead in Edmond and OKC.
OfflineFrank -
Yes, my California driving is a little lopsided and I need to work on evening it out.
Wow, the Mojave Desert Complex looks AMAZING! Thank you for the suggestion!
Yes, I have the most recent edition of EZ66, the Dining and Lodging Guide, Here It Is Maps, Mike Wallis' Mother Road, and I've been searching through an iPhone app I've had over the past year - it's map based - called "Road Trip 66" and is not a GPS, but has already helped me understand a ton about areas where there are multiple alignments, every attraction, dining & lodging. I've also watched a bunch of videos that outline the major attractions/dining/lodging.
Thank you so much for the daylight information - that is an enormous help - I can really schedule much more preceisely now.
I definitely want to hit Pops in the evening and am going to work on my MO and OK stops.
You are a wealth of knowledge, thank you so much for your advice! 

Lisa-- I spent several hours photographing during each of two stops at the Mojave Desert Complex in Goffs, and your interest may be greater than mine! An appointment is generally necessary.
All your research will pay off on the trip...starting with the best nightly stops which are not always intuitive. SharonT9084 has just posted results of her recent trip, in near-peak daylight.