OfflineDont know if my itinery went so here goes.
Chicago 2 nights
Springfield 1 night
St Louis 2 nights
Springfield 1 night
Tulsa 2 nights
Oklahoma 2 nights
Amarillo 1 night
Tucumari 1 night
Santa Fe 2 nights
Gallup 1 night
Grand Canyon 2 nights
Las vegas/Los Angeles 5 nights
Our main concern is distance between stops we want to do (150/200) mles per day. Dont want to rush between legs and miss something. Have hotels/motels in mind if this is doable. We have 3 days spare before heading to new york then home.

Bill--Welcome. That's a good plan. Let me suggest one change: Shamrock TX instead of Amarillo. This will lower your mileage for the day, allowing you to hit Route 66 museums in both Clinton and Elk City OK. They're very different, despite similar names. Another benefit: you can see and enjoy the art deco restaurant and adjoining gas station in Shamrock (featured in the "Cars" movies) near and after sunset--they're not impressive in strong sunlight. Your mileage the next day, to Tucumcari, is still fine.
After your Las Vegas sidetrip, there's a lot to see if you return to Rt 66 at Kingman AZ...instead of going straight to LA via Interstate. You have plenty of time to enjoy this. The info is here on the site.
OfflineHi Bill
We did Route 66 in May this year. With the exception of Chicago and Kingman, we didn't find it necessary to stay more than one night in any particular town/city.
As long as you are aware of the prevalence of tornadoes during this time of the year. We personally found the weather to be perfect, however, we just missed out on a tornado by twenty four hours in Oklahoma City. I don't know if it's normal or not, or just during that time of the year, but most of the time we felt we were the only car travelling along Route 66. The only place that we found an abundance of tourists, was at Seligman AZ.
Accommodation can be easily secured without lengthy bookings. We did ours each afternoon from a McDonalds restaurant.
wotacroc
Drove Route 66 in 2012.
OfflineHi Guys here is my update to route 66 may 2014
Chicago 2nights
Springfield(IL) seeing on the way artist bob waltmires bus/polka dot drive inn/the Gemini giant.
St Louis 2 nights seeing the gate archway/paddle steamer
Springfield(MO) 1 night on the way the rocking chair. anything else?
Tulsa 1 night been suggested that we stay in Claremore.
Oklahoma 2 nights. seeing national memorial/stock yards/route 66 museum. anything else?
Amarillo/Shamrock 1night art deco &cars location/u-drop inn petrol station/irish bar. anything else?
Tucamari 1 night seeing on way barbed wire museum/mid point café and sign.
Santa Fe 2 nights
Gallup 1 night
Williams 3 nights seeing on the way petrified forest/meteor city. intend to stay here and do the grand canyon train tour.
any better suggestions that you know of. thinking of doing the 3 night tour.
Kingman
Las vegas 2 nights
Needles 1 night
Barstow 1 night
Los Angles 4 nights seeing palisades park/Hollywood cemetery then onto Santa Monica for a well end beach rest
sadly then home. Okay guys your thoughts please and I would like some more must see.

Bill--It looks good and, in a way, relaxing with plenty of time to sightsee. Since there's plenty of time before you travel, getting the EZ66 Guide will be beneficial in your planning. It has a separate thread on the site.
All the popular attractions are listed in the Travel section at https://www.rt66pix.com in East-West order along with links to their websites. Classic motels too.
As for other things--check out the "Sidetrips from Route 66" thread on this site. And since you are going in May, you might be able to take part in the Golden Spike railroad event in Utah if that's of interest. It's not that far from Las Vegas.