OfflineShirley--
Try https://www.orbitz.com which searches several companies. Convertibles are in very high seasonal demand for Chicago-LA. If you really have trouble, you might try getting a regular car from Chicago to another large Rt 66 city, and then picking up a convertible there for the rest of the trip. Good luck!
OfflineHi Shirley,
We had the same issue. We're travelling May-June, and ending up taking good advice from the forum to hire a regular car with Hertz from Chicago to Las Vegas.
We're then getting a convertible Corvette for 2 weeks, it cuts the cost a bit to use a regular vehicle for the first stretch.
Sharon
For others in this situation, here's a GUESS on Rt 66 cities beside Chicago that might have convertibles available for one-way to LA. This is based on population, nothing more:
Springfield IL, St Louis MO, Springfield MO, Joplin MO, Tulsa OK, Oklahoma City, Amarillo TX, Albuquerque NM.
The last four tend to have shorter/milder winters, so convertibles may be in stock.